Home > Trade Tastings > Champagne & Chablis with Villeneuve Wines
Champagne & Chablis with Villeneuve Wines
Villeneuve Wines are an independent Scottish retailer with a reputation for maintaining an attractive list of wines and of course whiskies (regularly stocking more than 150 different malts). Sadly last year I had been unable to attend their annual Christmas tasting, and in truth my schedule wasn't much more favourable this year, as I only had an hour to spare. Nevertheless I was delighted to receive an invitation, and so I headed on down to the venire - Lyon & Turnbull, a fine art and antique auctioneer's house in central Edinburgh - on a cold and dark evening.
The range of wines on offer was broad, taking in both old and new world countries, a diverse array of styles and varieties. But time was short, and as a consequence I stuck with just two regions, Champagne and Chablis, tasting a handful of non-vintage wines from Pol Roger and Bollinger in the first instance, and then a broad look across the range of wines from the very competent Chablis co-operative, La Chablisienne.
It is always a little difficult reporting on non-vintage Champagnes, because the information can't be transferred to other bottles unless there is information on disgorgement provided (and that wasn't the case here, although Bollinger are doing that with the 2002 Grande Année I see). Nevertheless the wines do at least guide as to what is happening at the house in question. As for La Chablisienne, as has been my experience in the past there were some good wines here. I wasn't keen on La Sereine, seemingly an oak-heavy interpretation of Chablis, but otherwise these wines provide some very reasonable examples of the appellation. (8/12/10)
Champagne & Chablis with Villeneuve Wines - Tasting Notes
Tasted in November 2010. Click
to locate
stockists.
Pol Roger Pure Brut Nature NV: Current release.
Approximately one-third each of the three main varieties. This has a very clean
and herbal white fruit style, quite crystalline, suggestive of white grapes
coated in a little sugar crunch, also floral, with a little note of toffee
behind it. There is certainly a little creamy-caramel scent too. Still
very youthful on the palate, not totally composed, with some sweet whisky-mash
notes coming in at the edges. Youthfully disjointed and needing to come
together. Although there is a school of though that says zero-dosage
cuvées shouldn't be aged, this certainly needs to be left to integrate for a few
months at the very least.
Lovely freshness though; it should be fine given time. 16-17+/20
![]()
Pol Roger Brut Réserve NV: Current release.
As with the Pure Brut Nature served alongside, this is as usual a blend of
approximately one-third each of the three main varieties. This has much more meat to it
compared to the non-vintage 'Pure' cuvée, showing subtle elements of apple and
biscuit; the Pinot Noir in this blend seems to be rather more expressive. And there
is greater breadth to it on the palate as well, this certainly being the benefit
of a sensitive dosage. It
shows a fuller mousse and a more developed and integrated substance. Polished,
still rather reserved but this is certainly accessible. As is often the case, an
attractive wine. 16.5+/20
![]()
Bollinger Special Cuvée NV: Current release. This has a lovely character on
the nose, so obviously reflecting the Bollinger style. There are
notes of Brazil nut and papery fruit, rounded and expressing a presence yet also
suggesting a well-reined in style. But it has a crunchy definition. And that's
just how it comes across on the palate, showing here an exuberant and youthful
mousse with a broad, polished and harmonious style. This seems still rather
eager to please at present but all the necessary promise is here. Leave for a
year or two and it should be delicious. 17+/20
![]()
Bollinger Rosé NV: Current release. The typically pale yet slightly
golden-rosé hue that this non-vintage cuvée usually possesses. The nose has
a lovely and dense smoke-tinged fruit character, admittedly very close in style
to the Special Cuvée, with notes of peach and light citrus fruits alongside. On
the palate it seems very full but composed, elegant and nicely integrated. This
is certainly more ready and appealing right now than the Special Cuvée, perhaps
it has been hanging around in distribution and retail a little longer? A fine
and tingling mousse is part of an overall very stylish composition. This seems
to be a consistently delicious cuvée from Bollinger. 17.5+/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis Le Finage 2008: From vines averaging 20 years
of age, fermented in tank with malolactic, matured in tank. A clean and fresh nose, with a touch
of lanolin fatness to it, suggestive of some substance. This wine has a good
presence in the mouth, a savoury character showing some grip, with fresh acidity
too. Rather full, a good substance, and maintaining that grip through the
finish, also with an attractive touch of bitterness to it here. Good, and
certainly identifiable as belonging to the appellation. 15.5/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis La Sereine 2006: From vines averaging 20 years
of age, fermented in tank with malolactic, matured in tank and small barrels. Rather less typical of Chablis than
La Finage, with more of a fruit pastille sweetness to the nose, with a layer of
oak here too. There is a suggestion of slight reduction too. Rather a
full and polished style in the mouth, rounded off, here showing much more oak
than even the nose revealed, all new and golden and toasty. An interesting
expression of Chablis for sure, but not one that appeals to me. 14/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis Premier Cru Côte de Léchet 2007: From vines
averaging 25 years of age, fermented in tank and barrel with malolactic, matured
in tank and small barrels for 12 months. Not that expressive
on the nose, lightly polished oak which also comes through on the palate,
appropriate and not out of keeping with the wine. There is also a suggestion of
lift here, although it is subtle. Rather a well-rounded substance in the mouth,
soft and unfocused at first, although with more grip and a brighter character to
the fruit in the midpalate. Here it shows a little more zing and promise, as
suggested on the nose. Good potential but needs 3-5 years. 16+/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis Premier Cru Fourchaume 2008: From vines
averaging 25 years of age, fermented in tank and barrel with malolactic, matured
in tank and small barrels for 15 months. This has a much more
solid character on the nose than the Côtes de Léchet, a different vintage of
course. Polished fruit here, with a nice substance on the palate, very
substantial, a creamy citrus fruit character coming through the middle amongst
the oak which is also present here. It has a robust style. A great presence in
the finish though, savoury and full. Nice stuff. 16+/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis Premier Cru Vaulorent 2006: From vines
averaging 30 years of age, fermented in tank and barrel with malolactic, matured
in tank and small barrels for 15 months. Quite a linear style
presented here on the nose, with a very pure citrus-fruit definition, and with
touches of stone fruit coming in here too. This is certainly appealing. It has a
nice composition at the very start on the palate, polished and supple and with
some midpalate spice and grip. And a touch of sourness to the fruit adds some
more savoury aspects, along with a nice peppery vein. It does seem a little
withdrawn at present, but there is good substance here, and a long spicy finish.
Promising. 16.5+/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis Premier Cru Mont de Milieu 2006: From vines
averaging 25 years of age, fermented in tank with malolactic, matured in tank
and small barrels for 15 months. This is somewhat more funky on the nose. There
is just a little touch of cheese here which is hiding the fruit to a large
extent. And alongside I find some matchsticky reduction too, in fact more than a
touch. Good substance on the palate though, rather a solid composition, bold and
square without the same zing as some of the other wines although there is good
acidity at the very core. Certainly interesting. Nevertheless I wonder if this bottle may not be 100% typical and thus
I am reluctant to be conclusive with my score. 15-16+?/20
![]()
La Chablisienne Chablis Grand Cru Château Grenouilles 2004: From vines
averaging 40 years of age, fermented in tank and barrel with malolactic, matured
in tank and small barrels for 20 months. A suggestion of crunch to
the fruit on the nose here. And there are the beginnings of that slightly
golden, crystalline, honeyed element coming in at the edges, suggesting the
earliest signs of maturity. It is fairly expressive in that respect. Quite broad
style on the palate, composed, showing the same early-maturing character here,
relaxing into a softer, honey-tinged style, but still with some good acidity in
the middle keeping it fresh. The slightly fat substance does tend to overshadow
the structure a little though. Sour fruit character too. Still on the way up. 16+/20
![]()
