Home > Vintages and Regions > Bordeaux > Bordeaux CIVB Annual Tasting 2007
Bordeaux CIVB Annual Tasting 2007 Part 2
Part
two of the notes from this tasting features the wines of the right bank, not
only from St Emilion and Pomerol, but also from some less frequently encountered
appellations such as Fronsac and Lalande-de-Pomerol. My collection of notes then
rounds off with the sweet wines, which are of course largely from the left bank,
where the appellations of
Barsac and Sauternes are located, but also a few from nearby appellations,
including Cérons next to Barsac, and the Premières Côtes de Bordeaux and Loupiac
just across the river. As with the notes concerning the wines of the Médoc and
Graves presented in part one, the wines
range from those of minor estates to perhaps grander examples from more exalted
properties.
As before, I have included details
on stockists as well as prices (many of which do not include taxes and should
only be used as a guide) with the notes, along with wine-searcher (
) links to
facilitate price comparisons. I have noted that some wine-searcher prices can be
very favourable compared to those presented below, so it is certainly worth
shopping around. (6/11/07)
Bordeaux CIVB 2007 Part 2 - Tasting Notes
Tasted in October 2007. Click
to locate
stockists.
Chateau Carignan Prima (Premières Côtes de Bordeaux) 1999: A densely
coloured wine with a lovely nose here, of exotic and plump fruits. This is very
appealing and very well defined. There is fruit in abundance, and bright style,
with a moderately rich texture all underpinned by a firm acidity. There is some
grip as well. I think this has plenty of appeal and potential to do something in
the cellar too. Very good. 16-16.5+/20 (Corney & Barrow, £14.14)
![]()
Chateau Moulin Pey Labrie (Canon-Fronsac) 2000: This is a very dark
wine, and it although it doesn't start off with a very expressive nose it soon
opens out in the glass. A full style, quite plump, filled out with extract and
texture in a creamy style. Grippy substance, correct acidity and a good grippy
finish. Plenty of stuffing and potential for the cellar here. 16-16.5+/20 (Corney
& Barrow, £13.49)
![]()
Chateau Villars (Fronsac) 2001: It has been a while since I have
tasted anything from Chateau Villars. This has a rather dense colour, and isn't
showing much on the nose today. Light and lifted texture on the palate, reserved
and a touch stony, with nice grip. There is a lot structure here, beneath a
broad and fleshy style which holds nicely together as a result. A good, grippy
finish. I like it. 16+/20 (Justerini & Brooks, £9.41)
![]()
Chateau Corbin (St Emilion) 1999: A fairly dense hue, with
sandy-plummy fruit on the nose, presented in a dry and reserved style. A lovely
texture, ripe and creamy, quite rounded, with some spiciness to the mid-palate
grip. Very fleshy but also peppery and lively, plump fruit but with a backbone.
Broad and really rather appealing, and surprisingly good quality for 1999.
16.5+/20 (Corney & Barrow, £13.94)
![]()
Clos de la Cure (St Emilion) 2003: Rather sandy fruit on the nose
here, red and jammy, with a little not of confiture. On the palate it
starts off full but strangely seems to move towards a leanness through the
midpalate, and it also shows the hot texture of the vintage. It has quite a
little grip on the finish which tingles and prickles, but it isn't over the top.
There are some good points here. 15/20 (Boutinot, £14.49)
![]()
Chateau Teyssier (St Emilion) 2004: A Jonathon Maltus estate. A
really dark hue here, very dense right out to the rim. It has a slightly
reserved but very promising nose, with dark fruits and fading notes of honeyed
oak. Nice weight on the palate, creamy, but quite cool in style, before it shows
a denser, more meaty side through the midpalate. This has a fine, firm style
with a good backbone of acidity and ripe tannins at the finish. Very good
indeed, and a good deal at this price which results from overstocking.
16.5-17+/20 (Villeneuve, £9.99)
![]()
Chateau Laforge (St Emilion) 2004: Another Malthus wine, one that
features Cabernet Franc more than Merlot I think. A very deep purple hue here,
and an expressive nose to match. Full, plump and yet very well defined on the
palate, which has a nice, slightly minty style. It has a lot of texture but it
is well reined in with the help of some firm, acidity. It is full-on but very
nicely composed, and I like it. It could do with a little time in the cellar
though. 16.5-17+/20 (Justerini & Brooks, £17.60)
![]()
Chateau de Candale (St Emilion) 2004: A very dark wine with rather
sandy character on the nose, with some plummy notes alongside. Clean, attractive
and perhaps even exuberant though, and on the palate it shows a plummy, dark,
and grippy style. There is still a little nutty oak resolving, and a creamy,
rounded texture underpinned by a good structure. Appealing wine. 16-16.5+/20
(Waverley TBS, £12.99)
![]()
Chateau Fonplégade (St Emilion) 2004: A desperately dark, inky-opaque
wine. It has an appealing nose though, with plenty of expressive, spicy, exotic
character. The palate is perhaps unsurprisingly big, soft and creamy, although I
admit it has a good texture and some depth to compensate. It is meaty, cool, and
touch reserved at the end, and it does have quite good definition actually.
There is a fine grip underneath its voluptuous nature. Overall, for those that
like the big, impressive, flashy side of claret, this will be good choice.
17+/20 (Waverley TBS, £17.49)
![]()
Chateau des Anneraux (Lalande-de-Pomerol) 2003: A mature hue, rather a
medicinal nose, with hot cherries and candy cough-sweets. Rather stretched out
on the palate, with some grip underneath it all, some texture, but a prominent
medicinal character as found on the nose. I really don't like this. 12/20 (Villeneuve,
£14)
![]()
Chateau de Bel Air (Lalande-de-Pomerol) 2004: The colour here is
fading in a fairly advanced fashion for a 2004 I think. The nose is certainly
interesting, showing an unusual, seashell-stony character, and a little fleeting
note of organic compost. The body has appeal, although it is rather dry and a
touch oaky still, and there are some slightly coarse tannins. The finish is
gritty and marked by a little caramel and toffee. This is merely decent. 14/20
(Waverley TBS, £7.49)
![]()
Chateau Ferrand (Pomerol) 2003: Another wine with a mature,
red-oxblood hue. The nose is warmand full, exotic with a pretty floral edge. On
the palate though it is rather straight and lean, with peppery tannins which
quickly come to dominate the midpalate. It has a nice flavour but I find the
structure reflecting the vintage, and it is a touch too brutal for me. Lots of
grip on the finish, too, as you might expect. 14.5+/20 (Cockburns, £16.20)
![]()
Chateau Guillot (Pomerol) 2002: A dense, surprisingly mature hue,
showing some browning. A mature and open nose to match, rather perfumed with
notes of woodspice. Full, textured, very soft and rounded, creamy and yet
easy-going. It has soft acidity and there is not a lot of backbone to it. There
is little grip or tannin, and curiously there is a touch of balsamic to it.
Drink soon if you have any. 14.5/20 (Villeneuve, £20)
![]()
Chateau Certan Guiraud (Pomerol) 1998: The final vintage before this
property was divided, creating Chateaux Hosanna and Certan Marzelle. There is elegance on the nose
here, showing a restrained but characterful woodspice and plum. It is softly
composed on the palate, gently gliding and somewhat detached which I like. There
is a little grip through the midpalate, and good extract underpinning a nice
texture. Nicely composed but not a very firm style. I think this will be
drinking well very soon. 16.5+/20 (Corney & Barrow, £34.15)
![]()
And now the sweet wines of Bordeaux...
Chateau la Gontrie (Premières Cotes de Bordeaux Moelleux) 2004: A
vibrant golden hue. There is an intense honeyed character to the nose, which
also has a slightly medicinal and slightly raisined quality, perhaps reflecting
a long hang-time to obtain the effects of passerillage. It has a simple
but charming presence on the palate, with a sweet, somewhat confected style with
accents of oranges and vanilla, and a very creamy yet tangy texture. Appealing
and a decent drop at the price. 14.5/20 (Raeburn, £5.99 per 500ml)
![]()
Chateau Haura (Cérons) 2004: This has real appeal on the nose, which
has an elegant mineral and honey character, presented in a lifted and vivacious
character. It fills out nicely on the palate, which is packed with flavours of
honey, minerals and orange blossom. Nice correct acidity. An integrated, well
rounded, well-knit style. Excellent value for money. 16.5/20 (TM Robertson,
£10.99)
![]()
Chateau du Seuil (Cérons) 2004: A fine golden hue here. The nose is
quite delightful, full of notes of crisp candied pineapple, vanilla and glace
fruits. There is an exotic, spicy side to the palate which has a plump style,
over rather soft acidity but the flavours are very well defined nevertheless.
Very deep and characterful, with a slightly burny, caramel-orange edge and also
a little note of tropical fruit. An attractive wine. 15.5/20 (Matthew Clark,
£9.99 per 500ml)
![]()
Chateau du Cros (Loupiac) 2002: An appealing nose, full of lifted
honey and lanolin character. Rather well rounded out with a nice weight on the
palate, with some good flavour, backed up by a rather savoury, peppery, grippy
core. A plump style of wine but this is balanced by a nice acidic backbone
making this a very easy wine to drink. Good. 15.5/20 (Inverarity, £7.99 per
500ml)
![]()
Chateau La Rame Reserve du Chateau (St-Croix-du-Mont) 2000: A rather
smoky, minerally, organic nose here. A little residual sulphur still swimming
around in the mix also. Very well flavoured on the palate though, with some
dense orange peel and a streak of botrytis, backed up by a good acid backbone.
Creamy and dense, this has an appealing style which might even develop nicely in
the cellar if you can resist it now. 16.5+/20 (Friarwood, £20)
![]()
Ginestet 'Classique' (Sauternes) 2005: A fairly pale hue here, but
with an expressive and fresh pineapple nose. A lighter style is suggested, and
this seems true on the palate, where there is a nice body and grip apparent
through the midpalate but not a lot of complex character. It is clean, plump,
with notes of botrytis and oranges, but also with a little metallic twang too.
It is priced fairly but there are better wines to be had I think. 15/20 (Boutinot,
£9 per 500ml)
![]()
Lurton 'Les Garonelles' (Sauternes) 2004: A pale, mid-gold colour.
This has a fairly reserved style, with some candied fruit on the nose. It is not
so dense on the palate as some, and it perhaps is a little light on
concentration. Fresh though, nice vanilla flavour, with very appealing acidity.
But overall it doesn't have enough interest for me. 13.5/20 (Matthew Clark,
£9.99 per 375ml)
![]()
Rothschild 'Baronne Pauline' (Sauternes) 2003: The bottle is graced
with a distinctive image of Baroness Rothschild. A sweet and stylish nose
showing a complex blend of nettly freshness with a more gentle honey and lanolin
character. The palate is full, nicely complex, quite exuberant, plump but with
substance and texture too. There are plenty of positive points here, I must say.
It may cellar well too. 16.5+/20 (Baron Philippe, £23.99-£24.99)
![]()
Chateau Bastor-Lamontagne (Sauternes) 2003: A pale golden wine, with a
nose of honey, vanilla and lanolin. It is plump, creamy, rich and resinous,
although it lightens up somewhat through the midpalate. Not as much flavour here
as the texture demands, and lower acidity than is often the case with Bastor.
There isn't the usual definition I expect. Good though. 15.5/20 (Waverley TBS, at least
£7.50 per 375ml)
![]()
Chateau Briatte Cuvée Speciale (Sauternes) 2002: This has a fairly
light hue, with an interesting array of smoky, powdered rocks and minerals on
the nose. The palate follows on from this beginning, spiced with pineapple and
honeyed fruits presented in a very firm, acidic frame. Bright, tingling
freshness, even a little nettly. This is decent stuff. 14.5/20 (Corney & Barrow,
£14.81)
![]()
Les Carmes de Rieussec (Sauternes) 2002: The second wine of
Rieussec. An appealing, well defined
style with some reserved fruit character on the nose. Honey and pineapple again,
but elegantly composed, balanced and very nicely knit together. Rather
harmonious, fluid and well composed. There is a reserved style here like that on
the nose, and good style. A good second wine from a lesser vintage. 15.5-16+/20
(Alexander, £12.99 per 375 ml)
![]()
Chateau Suduiraut (Sauternes) 2002: A pale golden hue, and a subtly
honeyed nose, with not a lot of botrytis. Rather a soft style on the palate,
which has a fleshy, creamy style infused with vanilla, flower petals and
oranges. The acidity is fairly correct. It is attractive, elegant and although
it has lots of grip on the finish it is not a heavyweight. This is approachable
now, but will be better in a few years I think. 16-16.5+/20 (TM Robertson, £42)
![]()
Chateau du Levant (Sauternes) 1999: This does not seem too expressive
on the nose at first, with just some notes of creamy vanilla, although it is
more giving on the palate. Here there is more than a touch of orange and
grapefruit, with some botrytis character behind it all. There is even a little
streak of caramel, cut through by correct acidity. A dense and quite resinous
style which will appeal to many. 15.5/20 (Edinburgh Wine Importers, £7 per 375
ml)
![]()
Chateau Bastor-Lamontagne (Sauternes) 1999: A second vintage of this
wine. This has a mid-golden hue.
It is very fresh on the nose, with attractive lightly honey-coated fruits. On
the palate it is typical Bastor, with a lighter style than some others, fresh
and delicate rather than opulent, but nicely lifted by an incisive blood orange
acidity. This is very true to style for Bastor, which often seems to show this
firm body of acids I think. Good. 15.5/20 (Alliance, £14.49 per 375ml)
![]()
Chateau Broustet (Barsac) 1995: A fairly rich, golden hue on
inspection. The nose is certainly distinctive, with a rather organic nose, with
notes of smoky hillside bracken and minerals. There is a core of mineral on the
palate, but it seems quite disjointed and separate from the rest of the wines.
Around it there is a texture and a fruit profile matching the nose, but overall
it seems a touch steely and stripped out. 13.5/20 (Friarwood, £18.75)
![]()
Home - Site index - Site updated May 13, 2008 - © The Winedoctor 2000 - 2008 - Wine Scores - RSS
