Home > Wine Features > The 2011 Salon des Vins de Loire Top Ten
The 2011 Salon des Vins de Loire Top Ten
Last Friday an invited contingent of the UK wine press were fussing over the latest releases from Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, furiously scribbling notes on vinous objects that neither they nor 99% of their readers - if their notes or opinions are even published, of course - will ever be able to afford. I declined the invitation, a wise move as it turned out, as I had plenty of packing to do for my trip to Angers via Paris, with the wines of the Loire rather than Burgundy firmly on my mind. The cusp between January and February means only one thing to me: Salon time!
I suspect most wine journalists are very grateful for a thimbleful of the sacred DRC juice, and so Corney & Barrow's annual tasting will always draw a crowd. But it is depressing that so few of those same journalists are prepared to make the trip to the annual Salon des Vins de Loire (along with the associated Renaissance and Dive Bouteille tastings), events which together showcase the vast majority of the Loire Valley's wines, including almost all of the greats. Yes, there are a handful of significant domaines that don't participate, but for every notable absence there are five fabulous names there to replace them. And what is more, these are real wines. Not collector's objects, nor investment opportunities; there are no fund managers prowling the floor looking for the next profit opportunity here. Just lots and lots of great wines, white and red, dry and sweet, pétillant and tranquille. And of course every taste comes with a chance to meet the fascinating people behind these wines. It's an event I would be very sad to miss.
Where's the Salon Report?
Last year on my return to the UK I published a 2010 Salon Report, as I did in 2009. This year, having blogged on my daily impressions during the Salon, it seems rather superfluous and repetitive to provide a summary report. For my day-by-day updates, with news of where I've been, who I've been chatting too and what I have tasted, see my Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday blog posts.
So instead I will get straight to my favourite wines from the four days of tastings, ten wines which will excite the palate just as much as any red Burgundy. Some would say more so, in fact. They are also priced to buy and drink, rather than obsess over. As far as the domaines are concerned some, such as Domaine des Baumard and Bernard Baudry, are old favourites, whereas some are names new to Winedoctor. Watch out for my notes and profiles of Frantz Saumon, Xavier Weisskopf, Lise and Bertrand Jousset and Damien Laureau, all coming soon.
As I concentrated on Anjou and Touraine (specifically Savennières and Vouvray/Montlouis) this year, it is no surprise that my favourite wines can very easily be divided between these two principle regions. Let's kick off with Anjou; five lovely wines here, served up in no particular order. I've tried to maintain a focus on finished, bottled wines, but as you will see some barrel samples have slipped in here and there. (4/2/11)
As always there were some amazing sweet wines from the Layon appellations, especially from Quarts de Chaume in the 2007 and 2009 vintages, and I could so easily have included five such wines here. As it is I have managed to keep it down to just three, squeezing in one dry white and one red.
Domaine Ogereau Cot. du Layon St Lambert Clos des Bonnes Blanches 2007
![]()
Tasting with Vincent Ogereau on the first day of the Salon I was really taken
with his 2008 Anjou Blanc Sec, a really relaxed, fresh, elegantly poised wine.
But in terms of pure deliciousness, his sweeter wines stole the show. His 2009
Harmonie des Bonnes Blanches, a label created by Vincent to take his Bonnes
Blanches fruit in lesser vintages, picked up a Ligers d'Or, annual awards dished
out at the Salon, but for me his 2007 Clos des Bonnes Blanches was the real deal.
Domaine des Baumard Quarts de Chaume 2007
![]()
While I am on the subject of sweet wines from along the banks of the Layon, a
little further downstream from Bonnes Blanches, which lies opposite the imposing
Coteau des Treilles, is the vineyard of Quarts de Chaume. This Layon cru
has a diverse terroir and an array of different aspects on its four principal
slopes, and it yields some of the Loire Valley's greatest wines. There has been
some criticism of Florent Baumard (below, left) recently, his methods of viticulture and the
use of cryo-extraction, but you cannot deny the quality of what is in the glass.
This is a fine example of the appellation, showing a thick, quartzy seam of
minerality alongside the fruit and sweetness.
Damien Laureau Savennières Le
Bel Ouvrage 2007
![]()
Now to Savennières, a focus of mine during this year's Salon. Damien Laureau is
making Savennières in a more approachable style, with fermentation in barrique,
followed by an élevage of one year in the same wood, with 100% malolactic
fermentation. The wines are then assembled in cement cuves before bottling. I
just loved the barrel sample of 2009 Roches aux Moines cuvée, which had great
potential, but as that has yet to be bottled I have settled on this wine as an
example of his work. Laureau is definitely a name to watch in this appellation.
Dom. aux Moines Savennières Roches aux Moines Cuvée de L'Abbesse 2007
![]()
Whereas Damien Laureau is one of the better producers of a more modern, more
polished style of Savennières, those looking for the more upright austerity of
old-school could do a lot worse than come to the Laroche family of Domaine aux
Moines, where mother Monique and now daughter Tessa are turning out admirable
but very reserved and structured examples of the appellation. But they also try
their hand at sweet wines, producing the moelleux Cuvée des Nonnes and the sweeter Cuvée
L'Abbesse. This wine has 88 g/l of residual sugar and has a beautiful, quartzy
minerality to it. It is the closest quality to a top Quarts de Chaume that I
have ever experienced from outside that appellation. Where can I get some?

Domaine de la Bergerie Anjou-Villages Evanescence 2009
![]()
I was looking forward to tasting the wines of
Yves Guégniard (pictured above, right) this year, having met him at last year's
Stars of the Layon tasting.
His 2008 Savennières cuvées were fine and on a par with the 2007s previously
tasted, but I am afraid I am going to cheat a little and allow a barrel sample
in here, as his 2009 Evanescence seemed to be just brimming with potential. I
was impressed with his 2007 last year, as it was a really attractive wine
fashioned from a difficult vintage, but with more favourable conditions - as in
2009 - it is clear he has made something delightful.
There's nothing like consistency, is there? I wanted to include the 2008 Le Haut Lieu Demi-Sec from Domaine Huet here, but I see I featured that wine in my top ten from 2009. And the 2008 Clos Habert from François Chidaine was another stunner, but I see that wine featured in my favourite from last year. And the 2009 Romulus from Domaine de la Taille aux Loups was divine, but that's another choice from last year's list again. So they're all excluded I'm afraid.
That's a good thing I think. It is too easy to focus on the beauty of the Loire's sweeter cuvées, but we shouldn't become blinkered to other styles. Here are five dry wines that really impressed, the first four reflecting the Vouvray-Montlouis revolution, the final wine from a Chinon superstar.
Vincent Carême Vouvray Sec 2009
![]()
I visited Vincent and his wife Tania last summer, and thought the 2009 Sec was
lovely. Enough to buy some, certainly. This year it seems to taste even better,
showing a harmonious style but with more underlying structure to it than I first
spotted. There is vigour and minerality in this wine, which was more convincing
than wines from a number of 'bigger' names in the appellation.
Lise et Bertrand Jousset
Montlouis Singulier 2009
![]()
A new name on Winedoctor, the Joussets are making some delightfully defined
wines. They have Gamay, Grolleau and Chardonnay, but without a doubt the star
attractions here are the Montlouis wines. The house style is dry with a bright
and narrow seam of minerality and acid; Lise Jousset (below, right) has a taste for wines with
low residual sugar - she prefers less than 3 g/l! There were a number of good
wines here, but I've settled on this one, which is currently assembled in tank
prior to bottling.

Le Rocher des Violettes Montlouis
Touche-Mitaine 2009
![]()
Another dry Montlouis with a lovely structure to it, this wine - made by
Xavier Weisskopf (above, left) - has a fine
minerally backbone and a delightful grip and acid freshness. It's delicious. He
also fashions a couple of very impressive Touraine reds, using Cabernet Franc and Cot; it's rare to find Touraine reds that provoke my interest, with
Clos Roche Blanche being perhaps the best example of the appellation. Based on a
taste of his embryonic 2010s, Xavier's wines might well be on the same level.
He and his wife Clémence also have a very cute dog, so top marks all round!
Frantz Saumon Montlouis Mineral+ 2009
![]()
Frantz spent a long time as a forestier, in Quebec, before returning to his
native France, settling just down the road from
François Chidaine, to take up
viticulture. I found his wines, tasted last year at the Renaissance event, to be
very convincing. No change this year, and this cuvée, bottled last spring, was
my favourite of his offerings on the day.
Bernard Baudry Chinon La Croix Boisée 2009
![]()
Here's a wine I tasted last year and just adored, and happily my impression this
year - as the wine approaches the point of bottling - remains exactly the same.
This is one that I am going to have to add to the cellar. Meanwhile, the big
news here is that Bernard has now officially retired, and it is Matthieu that
has 100% control over the domaine. From what I tasted here, not just from 2009
but also from the embryonic 2010s, this isn't a handover that should cause us
any concern. Domaine Bernard Baudry is in safe hands, I think.
